The East Hampton community remains sharply divided over the potential reopening of the Maidstone Gun Club in Wainscott, as negotiations continue regarding the renewal of its lease on 97 acres of town-owned parkland. The club, which has been closed since 2022 following safety concerns, is seeking to resume operations under new terms that include enhanced safety measures and a significant rent increase.
The Maidstone Gun Club, a nonprofit organization with roots dating back to the 1930s, has operated at its current location near the East Hampton Airport since the 1980s. Historically, the club paid $100 per year for its lease, a rate that has come under scrutiny given the property’s current market value. The club has emphasized its commitment to safety and community engagement, noting that it serves both recreational shooters and local law enforcement.
In 2022, the club voluntarily ceased operations after residents of the nearby Merchants Path neighborhood reported that stray bullets had struck their homes. Although the club denied responsibility, an East Hampton Police Department investigation suggested that bullets may have originated from the club’s outdoor rifle range, passing through safety barriers. This led to a temporary restraining order and ongoing litigation involving the club, the town, and affected homeowners.
As lease renewal discussions progress, proposed terms include prohibiting outdoor rifle shooting, except for skeet and trap practice, and implementing additional safety protocols. The club has also agreed to a substantial rent increase and plans to invest in further safety enhancements, such as improved range infrastructure and monitoring systems.
Opponents of the lease renewal argue that the area’s transformation into a residential enclave makes the club’s presence untenable. They cite safety concerns, potential environmental impacts, and the desire for alternative uses of the land, such as affordable housing or public recreation spaces. Proposals from groups like the Coalition to Transform East Hampton Airport and Whalebone Workforce Housing suggest repurposing the land for community-beneficial projects.
Supporters of the gun club highlight its longstanding presence in the community, its role in promoting responsible firearm use, and its accessibility to individuals from various socioeconomic backgrounds. They argue that with appropriate safety measures, the club can coexist with the surrounding residential developments.
The East Hampton Town Board faces the challenge of balancing these competing interests as it considers the lease renewal. Council members have indicated that any agreement must include significant modifications to ensure public safety and address community concerns. The outcome of this decision will have lasting implications for the town’s approach to land use, public safety, and community development.
As negotiations continue, the future of the Maidstone Gun Club remains uncertain, reflecting broader debates about the coexistence of traditional institutions and evolving community dynamics.
